A Visionary 1933 Work of Fiction Has Found an Unexpected Second Life – Offering Insights for Our Times

A short while ago, I asked to an American acquaintance – as is common nowadays – concerning where he envisions "it" going, referring to the political landscape. He took a breath. "From my perspective, the United States occupies a comparable situation to the German nation in 1933-4," he stated. "It's crucial to wonder, could those subsequent years have been avoided? That's the juncture we are at. It's possible to claim fascism couldn't emerge in America. Yet in my view the outcome is unclear."

Rediscovering an Overlooked Masterpiece

This perspective appeared strikingly relevant for me because I had just finished reading a remarkable novel specifically concerning that exact period in Germany. Overlooked for generations, Sally Carson's set in Bavaria Crooked Cross received new publication in April through a specialty publisher. After its release, it has been a surprise hit, a jaw-dropper passed from hand to hand.

The Narrative Unfolds

Crooked Cross starts in late 1932 and ends at midsummer the following year. It takes place in the miniature, created Bavarian town called Kranach, a charming setting nestled in the mountains of the Alpine range. The narrative follows the Kluger family – a modest, middle-class family with caring parents with three mature offspring.

The atmosphere is warm and delightful and full of promise: the Christmas tree with decorations, the carefully wrapped gifts, the holiday music, the roasted goose.

All is gorgeously decorated, "even" – the reader shudders – "the photograph of the leader that sat upon the piano."

The Writer through Her Contribution

The author created two subsequent novels to Crooked Cross. The entire trilogy came out before World War II. Later, in 1941, in her thirties, she died of cancer. This book was well reviewed upon publication, but didn't cause major impact and soon sank without trace.

An impressive element regarding this work is its immediacy. It was written as things unfolded, and released promptly. The brief duration that it covers represented a time of significant political shifts.

Historical Context

  • Hitler became chancellor
  • They obtained parliamentary control
  • Dachau was opened
  • Jews were barred from public-service jobs

In the beginning, the family members exchange greetings with a cheery Grüss Gott; by the end, the family patriarch is using the Nazi salute acquaintances in the street and the local church bells were changed so that they chime using the melody of the Nazi anthem.

Current Importance

Studying this work, armed with the hindsight that Carson herself lacked, proves extraordinary, sometimes difficult. For us in 2025, each element she depicts is rushing towards a single unavoidable outcome: the war, the genocide.

What's remarkable concerning the writer remains, even though she couldn't know what the ultimate outcome would be, the book possesses a firm ethical foundation.

No ambiguity exists. The measures implemented throughout the country against Jewish citizens, to political opponents, is obviously awful, according to the novel's worldview.

Enduring Influence

Carson shows us the way radicalism, when it takes hold, gives these people with purpose, employment, an explanation, hope and distinct functions. Additionally, it offers them specific targets – leftwingers and Jews – to despise, to accuse, to penalize and, quite quickly, to beat and to murder.

The similarities with the present are impossible to overlook. How fortunate we'd be shared her perception and her principled vision.

Elizabeth Richardson
Elizabeth Richardson

A beauty enthusiast and certified skincare specialist sharing evidence-based tips and personal experiences to help you achieve your best glow.